Showing posts with label romance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label romance. Show all posts

Monday, December 2, 2019

The Importance of Kristoff

We talk about this a lot in my Disney classes, but so often, it's the female characters who are the focus of at best discussion, at worst criticism in Disney films. (With the exception of Pixar. Because Pixar has this weird obsession with male leads. And just when we think they're making progress with films like Brave and Toy Story 4, which feature Merida and Bo Peep & Jessie, we get Onward. Don't even get me started on Onward. I am...not impressed by the trailer.)

And while the heroines (and, to some extent, the villains) of Disney Princess movies aren't necessarily fully-fleshed out characters, they're at least better than the Disney Princes. After all, Snow White's prince doesn't even have a name (I refuse to believe it's "Florian"), and Cinderella's love interest is known simply as "Prince Charming". It's not until we get to Sleeping Beauty that the prince even has a name and actual dialogue. 

This is, of course, something that's changing in more recent films. Speaking of the 2015 live-action Cinderella, screenwriter Chris Weitz says,
"Prince Charming is something of a cypher in the animated (1950) version and the Grimm and Perrault talks. I felt that whereas it was acceptable and even useful to have him be essentially symbolic in earlier versions (it was just enough that he was rich and important and handsome), an audience today demands a bit more in terms of identification."
Kristoff isn't technically a prince (yet) -- I'm hoping for a Frozen III where Kristoff and Anna get married and Elsa brings Honeymarren as her date -- but the ideas are the same: it's not enough that he's Anna's True Love, we have to know more about him to understand why Anna loves him. (Frankly, his relationship with Sven is enough for me: he's goofy and good with animals.)

And, as Kristen Bell points out to Jimmy Fallon, it's equally important to know why he loves her and to see him loving her. It's not something we get enough of, and can go a long way in changing the narrative that leads to Toxic Masculinity.



Thursday, September 21, 2017

#tbt

Just going to sneak this #tbt post in under the midnight deadline...

Facebook reminded me today that, 5 years ago, we made our engagement "Facebook official." (Because of course it's not official until it's Facebook official. 😒) So, in honor of that, I wanted to share a photo of my "Disney engagement":


I had always dreamed of getting engaged in front of Cinderella Castle in the Magic Kingdom. Cliche, I know, but to my Disney-princess obsessed self, that seemed the epitome of romance. (Plus, all of the families on the 90s sitcoms I grew up with had a Disney-episode, and I'm pretty sure one of them involved an engagement in front of the castle.) And, TBH, it still kinda does. I know princesses and fairy tales and uber-romanticized happily-ever-afters don't exist, but Disney is the place where they at least seem possible.

So my wonderful, thoughtful, creative husband did this. We had a trip planned for October with our moms, and he thought about proposing then, but (1) he did think it was a little cliche and (2) he didn't want to have to worry about traveling with and packing a ring, let alone carrying it around a Disney park all day. (What if it fell out of his pocket on Space Mountain? I mean, his cell phone did, so it could happen. Luckily, we did get the phone back.)

So he brought Cinderella Castle to me. And dragged me out of bed before 8 on a Friday morning, without coffee, because he couldn't wait. 💖

And, bonus: even though our engagement didn't take place in front of Cinderella Castle, our engagement photos did. Because he proposed a few weeks before our trip, we got to plan to have engagement photos taken in the Magic Kingdom, and that's something that I will treasure forever.


Wednesday, February 15, 2017

Disney Wedding Special Coming to Freeform (a.k.a. ABC Family)

Disney is basically synonymous with "childhood" and "innocence" -- or, at least, that's the idea the company has worked hard to cultivate. 

But Walt Disney famously once said, 
"I do not make films primarily for children. I make them for the child in all of us, whether we be six or sixty."
And the Disney Parks are family vacation destinations -- after all, the best package prices are for a family of four (two adults, two children). Leaving aside the implications of this (what if you have a bigger family/more than two kids? what if you have a smaller family? what if you go with friends? what if you go with your someone special?),  Disney has never been just for children.

Lately, though, they have been consciously expanding their consumer base -- or, at least, their appeal to their consumer base. That is, parents are the ones who decide to take their kids, so adults are kind of always there. But, recently, there's been a clear effort to appear to parents as "adults," and not just as "caretakers of the tiny humans" (which, as a parent myself, I appreciate). That's the reason Disney has sunk a lot of money into the Downtown Disney (I think it's called Disney Springs, now?) renovation with restaurants and nightlife as well as into their restaurants.

But, perhaps most indicative of Disney's attempt to appeal to adults (specifically adult women) is their Fairy Tale Weddings.

And, if you want to learn more, you can soon watch a 90-minute special on fairy-tale weddings on Freeform. According to Broadway World (because I refused to link to US Weekly):
"The 90-minute special, which will air this spring 2017, will give viewers a behind-the-scenes look at the magical weddings and one-of-a-kind engagements that take place at Disney Destinations around the globe, including Walt Disney World, Disneyland and Disney Cruise Lines. From fashion and products to world-class entertainment and décor, viewers will get a glimpse of the modern day fairy tale that Disney's Fairy Tale Weddings brand has been creating for 25 years."

#consumerism.

Sunday, May 29, 2016

Why Elsa Shouldn't Have A Girlfriend


Trending Hashtag Right Now: #GiveElsaAGirlfriend 

Also trending: #GiveCaptainAmericaABoyfriend. (Clearly this was before Marvel revealed that the comic book world's Golden Boy was a sleeper agent for the Nazis Hydra. Or maybe that doesn't matter.)

This may be a controversial thing to say but...I don't support either of these campaigns.

Now, let me clarify this: I'm definitely not saying I don't support LGBTQ+ rights. I'm definitely not saying I don't want to see a homosexual relationship in a Disney film. I'm definitely not saying I don't want to see a homosexual character in a Disney film.

I am saying that I just don't think that either Elsa or Captain America is that character. 

A little bit of background:

This all started when Twitter user lexi4prez tweeted this out:


According to her own essay on MTV,  the motivation for her Tweets is 100% valid. She starts her essay, for instance, by noting what she doesn't/hasn't seen:
"Growing up, I never saw a princess fall in love with another princess — and neither have girls growing up right now. The entertainment industry has given us girls who have fallen in love with beasts, ogres who fall for humans, and even grown women who love bees. But we’ve never been able to see the purity in a queer relationship."
The lack of homosexual characters in children's media isn't a new issue -- or an inaccurate one -- in children's media scholarship. Critics have pointed out that children's media in particular focuses on heterosexual relationships, with the traditional "happily ever after" usually being a marriage between a man and a woman. And Disney, as one of the giants in children's media. is often lambasted for its lack of diversity in many ways, not just with regards to homosexual characters.

SIDEBAR: As influential as Disney can be, it can be fairly reluctant to take a step that would anger its middle-class fanbase: it won't take a step in a progressive direction unless it knows it won't financially hurt them. That is, while there hasn't been a homosexual character in an animated film, the company is by no means anti-LGBT. The Disney Channel show Good Luck, Charlie featured a lesbian couple; the ABC show Once Upon A Time has the bisexual Mulan (and Ruby); and the fact that Disney World has specifically designated LGBT friendly days (Gay Days, usually in early June) has angered more than a few conservative groups. But feature-length animated films are the company's bread-and-butter, and they're going to be extra cautious.

And she concludes with an equally valid point:
"Giving young girls the chance to understand that a princess can love another princess the same way Cinderella loved her Prince Charming is vital to their development. No one deserves to feel isolated and confused about who they are. All we need is someone to show us that there are other options, other kinds of princesses, and other ways to have the happy ending that you deserve."
Yes, "no one deserves to feel isolated and confused about who they are." And, yes, it is important to show girls "that there are other options, other kinds of princesses, and other ways to have the happy ending that you deserve." I agree with this 100%.

But this is also where I start to disagree. Because while I agree that Disney needs be more diverse, needs to have a homosexual character and, one day, needs to show a homosexual relationship, I really don't believe that Elsa is that character, nor should she be.

Earlier in the easy, Alexis Isabel makes this statement:
"Yet Elsa, the film’s protagonist, will probably end up with a male prince or king in the upcoming Frozen sequel."
I understand where this concern comes from: every single Disney Animation Studios Princess before Elsa has ended up with a man in some way. I'm excluding Merida since she has the (more progressive) Pixar behind her story.
[SIDEBAR: It's interesting to note that only four Disney princesses actually get married (in the film itself, not in sequels or shorts): Cinderella, Ariel, Rapunzel, and Tiana -- and Flynn Rider only tells us that he and Rapunzel get married in the "epilogue" of the film. Snow White, Aurora, Belle, and Jasmine are merely shown with their princes at the ends of their films, usually dancing off screen with them. Pocahontas, of course, ends up alone; and Mulan merely invites Shang to dinner.]

So I get it. The temptation to pair Elsa with a man is there -- although I sincerely hope that Chris Buck and Jennifer Lee developed a better story than that. And I'd be lying if I didn't think the Internet's obsession with shipping Elsa & Jack Frost (from Rise of the Guardians) isn't absolutely adorable and perfect. I even own a TeeTurtle shirt with them building a snowman together.

But that doesn't mean I want to see them end up together in a Frozen sequel.

And here's why: there was nothing -- and I'm not counting the lyrics of "Let It Go," since the power of that song comes from the myriad of situations it can be applied to -- in the original film that implied or even hinted at Elsa's sexuality.

And that was the brilliance of it.

Because, again, yes. It's important to have a homosexual character in a Disney animated film -- but only if it is true to the character and the story.

Yes, it is important to have "other kinds of princesses, and other ways to have the happy ending that you deserve." But the emphasis here is on "kinds" -- plural. Not just another "kind" of princess -- singular. There are other options besides a straight princess in a heterosexual relationship and a gay princess in a homosexual relationship. There can, for instance, be a princess queen who is "enough" on her own -- who is strong and independent and resourceful.

I'm not saying she needs to be completely isolated -- that is, after all, the point of the first movie.  We need other people in our lives, our friends and family.

But for me, one of the most progressive aspects of the original film was that Elsa didn't need to be married to rule her country. There was no annoying subplot where she had to be married in order to become queen. (Which is, unfortunately, the plot of The Princess Diaries 2, itself a Disney princess film. Mia can't rule Genovia without being married. And while, in the end, she does give a powerful speech extolling the virtues of female rulers, and the law is overturned, it's still the plot of the movie.) Here, in Frozen, it's not even an issue, it's not even mentioned: the King and Queen of Arendelle die, Elsa turns 21, she's crowned as queen. There's no meeting of Parliament to decide whether she should take the crown; when she spazzes out and unleashes an eternal winter, no one mentions her gender (they mention her "evil magical powers," but that's completely unconnected to gender); and no one says anything about how a man would have been a better ruler. After all, the male authority figures in the film are largely ineffectual (excluding Grandpabbie, as he's a troll): the King of Arendelle is in the running for Worst Parental Advice Ever (when he tells Elsa to suppress her true self); the Duke of Weselton is an ineffectual dignitary with a Napoleon complex; and Hans...well, Hans seems like he could have been a good ruler (he did take care of the people when Anna was searching for Elsa), but he's too power-hungry and narcissistic to really rule well. (Plus, he's the villain.)

This is just as important a message, just as important an image, for little girls (and boys!) watching Frozen to see. You don't need to be in a relationship to be successful: you are capable of great things on your own. Yes, you need friends and family to keep you grounded, but a relationship isn't the only way to define happiness.

So while a gay Disney princess would be great, I still don't think it should be Elsa. Let Elsa rule Arendelle as a strong, empowered monarch and leave the romantic subplot out of it. The first truly gay Disney princess should be a character worthy of that storyline.

[SIDEBAR: All of this applies to Captain America, too. I get it. He and Bucky have an awesome bromance fraught with tension that people love to read stuff into. BUT. Cap loved Peggy Carter. That's like a big point of this most recent film: he goes to London for her funeral (because he loved her), and it's Sharon's recollections of her aunt's advice that cause Cap to not join with Tony Stark and whatever UN accords they're agreeing to. (Again, because Cap loved Peggy. And may or may not have had a thing with Black Widow. And may or may not have a thing with Sharon Carter, because that's not weird at all.) So, yes: it wouldn't be true to his character or his storyline. At least not in the Marvel movies; the comics have shown that Cap's identity and character are apparently pretty fluid, so, yeah.]


Monday, March 2, 2015

Cinderella on the Brain

With the live-action adaptation of Disney's Cinderella hitting theaters in just a couple of days, Cinderella seems to be everywhere.

A couple of days ago, Duke University's Facebook page posted a link to the following: an interview with Assistant Professor of Sociology (at Duke) Jessi Streib, titled "What Happens When Rich People Marry Poor People."


The article is an interesting read -- and it comments a lot on class divisions and gender roles, something I'm always fascinated by. 

But I'm not blogging about the content -- I'm not a sociologist, and, regardless, I don't disagree with her conclusions; on the contrary, I find them really interesting.

But I am a children's literature/Disney scholar, and so what piqued my interest was the decision to put the disney photo of Cinderella and Prince Charming underneath the article title. As far as I can tell -- since there's no mention of Disney or Cinderella in the interview -- the implication is that the "rich people" are represented by Prince Charming and the "poor people" are represented by Cinderella. After all, the story of Cinderella is often referred to as a rags-to-riches story wherein the penniless scullery maid rises through the ranks to marry the eligible and charming prince. 

But...here's the thing that gets me: Cinderella may be penniless, she may be a maid, and she may sleep in the attic and sit in the ashes but she's not from the lower class. 

The "original" version by Perrault is a little vague on the subject -- depending on the translation, her father is either a "gentleman" or a "worthy man." Her stepmother is described as a proud and haughty woman and the family is obviously well-enough off to afford rich clothes and jewel suitable for balls at the palace. Similarly, in the Grimms' version, the father is described as a "rich man." 

Then, in the 1950 Disney version, the film opens while Cinderella's father is still alive: the storybook narrator tells us that, "Here, in a stately chateau, there lived a widowed gentleman and his little daughter, Cinderella. Although he was a kind and devoted father, and gave his beloved child every luxury and comfort, still he felt she needed a mother's care. " 

So, here's the thing -- and one of the things that always bothers me about adaptations of Cinderella -- if Cinderella's father is rich and is a gentleman, then Cinderella is the daughter of a rich man and a gentleman. Until her father remarries, she grows up in a pretty luxurious atmosphere -- she's not royalty, but she's most likely a member of the nobility or the upper-class. 

But that fact seems to get lost in adaptation -- and it's always bugged me. 

Take Ever After (1998) for instance. I loved this movie when it came out -- heck, I still do: Drew Barrymore as a feistier, hard-working Cinderella who reads? Da Vinci as her fairy godmother? Yes, please. The plot hinges on the fact that Danielle (as Cinderella is called here) poses as a noblewoman to get her servant back (long story). She gives her mother's name -- and her mother was a countess. But somehow, even though her mother was a countess, Danielle is still considered to be a serving girl -- and hijinks straight out of Pride & Prejudice ensue, resulting, of course, in a happily ever after. It's true that her father isn't really referred to as a count -- just her mother as a countess. And it's true that her stepmother (played by the incomparable Anjelica Houston) seems to be a Baroness in her own right. So maybe Danielle's parents were of different classes -- the countess married someone well beneath here and was hence stripped of her title. But the chateau that Danielle lives in -- her family home and estate -- doesn't really reflect that. 

So maybe I'm missing some integral part of French class divisions -- that a daughter is stripped of her titles and status when her father dies. But...that seems odd. 

In all of these versions, Cinderella is born into the upper-class -- and so, to me, her marriage to the Prince can't represent an inter-class marriage. Yes, her evil step-family treats her horribly: they psychologically abuse her; they degrade her and relegate her to the position of servant; they ostracize her from the family dynamic. Does that mean she's not still a member of the upper-class? Technically, perhaps. But in spirit? No.

And isn't that the point of Cinderella? Especially of the 1950 version? That even though she's fallen from her position of privilege, even though she's serving the people who are supposed to be her family, even though life has thrown her some horrible curveballs, Cinderella's kindness and sweetness and goodness triumph over all. She's defined by her heritage and her birth and her parents' -- particularly her mother's -- legacy, not through current circumstances. And when the Prince falls in love with her and they get married, it makes sense: they are both good, kind, upper-class people so of course they should end up together. 

Disney's Cinderella has got a lot going on -- particularly with regards to heteronormative gender roles and the stoic passivity with which Cinderella accepts horrible treatment. But, it was released in 1950, and things were different. But introducing class into the movie...I'm not sure that's a fair criticism. After all, Disney's narrator explicitly states that Cinderella's father, for his second wife, chooses a "woman of good family" -- which I take to mean "good breeding" which in turn implies "upper class." So class doesn't really come into play here: our heroine's a member of the upper-class as is our villain. 

If Cinderella had been an actual servant who rose through the ranks -- if she hadn't been a step-daughter -- then we might have a rags-to-riches story. Given the title of the article, there are a couple other Disney movies that would have been more appropriate. 

Like, for instance,  Beauty and the Beast: Belle grows up in a small provincial town (we're hit over the head with that, aren't we?) but she eventually marries the Beast, who is, in fact, a prince. Inter-class marriage.

In Aladdin, Aladdin is literally a street rat, the diamond in the rough. But he eventually marries Princess Jasmine. Inter-class marriage.

In Tangled, Flynn is literally a thief. But he eventually marries Princess Rapunzel. Inter-class marriage.

And in The Princess and the Frog, Tiana works not one, but two, jobs to raise enough money to open her own restaurant. But she marries Prince Naveen in a -- you guessed it -- inter-class marriage. 

If you want to include a picture from a Disney movie in an article about marriages between rich people and poor people, I'm not sure Cinderella was the best choice here. Yes, it's the quintessential rags-to-riches story, but, if you think about, it's actually more of a riches-to-rags-to-riches story. I have a feeling that Cinderella and Prince Charming would probably not have the same fights and discussions in their marriage that Aladdin and Jasmine or that Tiana and Naveen would have. 

But, of course, they all lived happily ever after so class differences probably don't matter for them.